The biggest mistake Rommel did during World War II was crossing into Egypt, despite being ordered and advised not to. ThunderboltFan (Wed 03 Feb 2010 12:58:42 AM EST) show full. Admittedly, Montgomery had enjoyed a substantial material superiority to Rommel, but the victory was sufficient. Let us know what you think … by Larso » 20 Jan 2011, 14:01. Hitler's main man had been tricked by a master of illusions. He did say one time when speaking in the House of Commons about Erwin Rommel in 1942: "We have a very daring and skillful opponent against us, and, may I say across the havoc of war, a great general." This young officer knows the war very early because in 1914, at the beginning of the First World War, he was only 23 years old. It is believed Montgomery had requested a copy of the account as, despite being enemies, he and Rommel had a great respect for one another. Monty by his own admission won by sheer materiel (which is just fine in my view) but Zhukov won often outnumbered and having inferior equipment. Berlichtingen, while I think Rommel, manstein and Guderian are obsiously generals of greatness, they did lose to Zhukov and Monty. Montgomery was a great believer in training troops over and over again. Without having the exact quotes to hand, Rommel also wrote about the Australians being 'emmensly big and powerful men' or something along those lines. Holmes thinks Rommel's presence would not have made much difference. With George C. Scott, Karl Malden, Stephen Young, Michael Strong. El Alamein a crucial turning point in WWII, says noted historian. Erwin Rommel Following are some excerpts from The Rommel Papers (1953), which reproduces some letters from Rommel to his wife, in three of which he mentions Australian soldiers. Montgomery was a competent general with superior intelligence, superior supply and superior numbers and he ground Rommel down. Smart, Men, Giving. Field Marshall Erwin Rommel, also known as "The Desert Fox" and was considered a humane officer and the most highly skilled desert combat … Imagine if there were 2,000,000 Jews living in Palestine. When Montgomery took over the 8th Army he had two battles to fight before tackling the enemy. He was undoubtedly one brave bastard and a good officer at lower ranks but as a general, he was strategically mediocre at best. This gave Montgomery time to prepare and ruined any chance of surprise. Erwin Rommel was born at noon on November 15th, 1891, at Heidenheim, a small town in Würtemburg, near Ulm. 1,115. There's also an argument for Kesselring and Model. They did not harm Rommel’s family. I don’t think Winston Churchill liked any Germans ever in his life. On this occasion, the Nazis actually kept their word. The contrasting and comparison of these three Generals is fascinating. 1891–1944. When World War II ended in Europe in May 1945, most Western military leaders and analysts regarded Erwin Rommel as the war’s greatest German general. Soon, Montgomery penetrated the north and won the battle. You cannot compare Rommel with Montgomery. Both of them were great tacticians. But I have to point out one thing. Montgomery had plenty of troops and supplies with him during the Battle of El Alamein. On the other hand for Rommel's troops were exhausted and their tanks were running out of fuel. Bernard Montgomery 1st Viscount Montgomery Of Alamein Erwin Rommel Wikiquote Get Best Quotes By Erwin Rommel To Share ... What Did General Rommel Think Of Americans Soldiers Quora Rommel And His Art Of War Greenhill Military Paperbacks Erwin Rommel Alchetron The Free Social Encyclopedia Rommel’s offensive at Alam el Halfa began on the night of 30—31 August, 1942. Having proven to be a skilled commander in his previous missions, Rommel had earned the respect of his troops, and that of his enemies. Terry Brighton did a great job of defining the character of 3 of the most important generals of the war - George S. Patton , Bernard Montgomery and Erwin Eugen Rommel. Though he was a good divisional commander for the 7th he … The Rommel myth, or the Rommel legend, is a phrase used by a number of historians for the common depictions of German field marshal Erwin Rommel as an apolitical, brilliant commander and a victim of Nazi Germany due to his presumed participation in the 20 July plot against Adolf Hitler, which led to Rommel's forced suicide in 1944. I have read biographies of Patton and Rommel, but this book is a worthwhile supplement to my previous knowledge. Monty DID revise his plan, and did so several times. At no time did Rommel have more than 4.5 divisions of Germans under his command. Montgomery's father inherited his father Sir Robert Montgomery's estate of New Park at Moville in County Donegal, Ireland, United Kingdom soon after Montgomery… [684], Rommel was an ambitious man who took advantage of his proximity to Hitler and willingly accepted the propaganda campaigns designed for him by Goebbels. Both born in November which is kind of interesting. It was their first real victory against the Axis. Contributor: C. Peter Chen ww2dbase Bernard Law Montgomery was born in Kennington, London, England, United Kingdom to Anglo-Irish Anglican priest Reverend Henry Montgomery and Maud Montgomery, née Farrar. But that was not how most German military leaders felt. Rommel wasn't much different from Patton in that regard either. Thus, Rommel was not even in North Africa when Montgomery’s opening blows in the second Battle of El Alamein fell on Axis positions in October. From the Nazi POV this was damning. Napoleon Bonaparte. Liddell Hart described British efforts to make counterpropaganda against Rommel's military reputation (while showing respect to his conduct of war): "Thus the British commanders and headquarter staffs were compelled to make strenuous efforts to dispel 'the Rommel legend'". Without having the exact quotes to hand, Rommel also wrote about the Australians being 'emmensly big and powerful men' or something along those lines. It was interesting to learn the fact that all 3 men were born in November between 1885 and 1891 making all 3 Scorpios. In addition, Rommel was severely short of fuel. In 1910, he enlisted as a cadet to the 6th Battalion, 124th Infantry Regiment, at Weingarten, and in 1912 he received his lieutenant’s certificate. Rommel was give the choice of a show trial, conviction, and certain death as a traitor or suicide, a state funeral, and the assurance that his family would be safe. By Bundesarchiv – CC BY-SA 3.0 de. It is possible that Rommel had much admiration for Montgomery after they lost the North African campaign but had he known about the broken enigma I am sure such admiration would be diminished. On 22 June, Hitler promoted Rommel to Generalfeldmarschall for this victory. Erwin Rommel was born in Württemberg, Germany, in 1891. by Larso » 20 Jan 2011, 14:01. 508 Copy quote. Monty was also thinking ahead of Rommel in the game of coordinating air operations with the ground battle. Panzerarmee Afrika was a broken reed, a mere shadow of its former self. By Montgomery’s orders, his tanks were not committed but conserved for later operations, as they had been at Alam Halfa in September 1942. British Field Marshal Sir Bernard Montgomery has gone down in history as the victor of El Alamein and the relentless nemesis of Field Marshal Erwin Rommel, Nazi Germany’s famed “Desert Fox.” But Monty’s feat was merely a repeat of that of the British general who preceded him, a general who defeated Rommel not once, but twice. Montgomery and Rommel were great adversaries in the WWII front lines; their sons, on the other hand, David Bernard Montgomery and Manfred Rommel … Rommel did not have the men or equipment he needed. He resented that Eisenhower was his superior, openly expressing disdain and privately belittling his generalship. https://www.theoldie.co.uk/blog/what-rommel-said-about-montgomery However, he was a lousy strategist, and that was his biggest weakness. After striking successes at the battles of Battle of Caporetto and in the capture of Longorone in Italy, Rommel was promoted to the rank of captain in January 1918. He probably never knew of the plot to kill Hitler. Before he ordered the attack, Montgomery launched a deception campaign to make Rommel think that he is planning to attack him from the south. Erwin Rommel was a German Field Marshal during that same era. By the time the battle started he had almost twice as many troops, tanks and aircraft as the German commander Rommel. Alexander the Great. Highly complicated man, but confusing too. On 15 July he wrote to his superiors that since D-Day he had lost 97,000 men, but had … - or something like that. He fought primarily on the western front, mostly in France and Italy. But this directness made him a great military leader. In August 1942, Winston Churchill put Montgomery in command of the 8th Army, which had just been defeated by Erwin Rommel’s Afrika Korps. In the Second World War, the United States, Great Britain, and Germany each produced one land-force commander who stood out from the rest: George Patton, Bernard Montgomery, and Erwin Rommel. Patton: Directed by Franklin J. Schaffner. Field Marshal Erwin Rommel surveys the battle near the wreckage of a British Bren gun carrier. Going through a research binge about war generals lately and Erwin Rommel stood out immediately. From memory these were prisoners he was observing and I think he … The Desert Generals is packed with information but one fact stood out. May 4, 2015. 564 Copy quote. Montgomery was no genius, as the British want us to think. Criticism of Montgomery simply falls away when one considers the fact that he planned it to take 90 days, and it did, he crushed Rommel for the second time, and Von Rustend, The silly arguments about Patton and fuel also fall away when it became clear that the broad front strategy was a political not a military decision. Having been driven east by Axis forces in 1942, the British had established a strong defensive line at El Alamein, Egypt. But to reach the Axis forces, the Allies first had to cross the so-called Devil's Garden, a 5 mile wide mine field which separated the two armies. I think Claude Auchinleck was a very great General, he beat Rommel twice, once during Crusader, and again at 1st Alamein. McMahon argues that Rommel no doubt possessed operational vision, however Rommel did not have the strategic resources to effect his operational choices while his forces provided the tactical ability to accomplish his goals, and the German staff and system of staff command were designed for commanders who led from the front, and in some cases he might have chosen the same options as Montgomery … Montgomery - generally too cautious Patton - sometimes too agressive. ‘ He was basically running almost out of troops, tanks, equipment, basically everything. Rommel’s offensive at Alam el Halfa began on the night of 30—31 August, 1942. 'You can be proud of your achievements', Hitler wrote. Montgomery was able to build back the confidence of his troops. The near-fatal strafing of his command car on July 17, 1944, provided just the right camouflage for the Desert Fox's death; a Nazi-regime forced suicide. Montgomery’s predecessors lacked even that basic competence. He was undoubtedly one brave bastard and a good officer at lower ranks but as a general, he was strategically mediocre at best. What key to Montgomery and Rommel, and I think nearly. Montgomery never had his theatre responsibilities in the Middle East, or the material shortcomings Auchinleck laboured under. "By November 2nd 1942, Rommel knew that he was beaten. However, Rommel was really a better general than Montgomery was. Stranded in the desert, the Axis forces dug themselves in, and laid minefields. To stave off the invasion, Hitler chose Field Marshal Erwin Rommel, the brazen veteran of the North Africa campaign. Monty by his own admission won by sheer materiel (which is just fine in my view) but Zhukov won often outnumbered and having inferior equipment. In the fall and winter of 1942-1943 the fox seemed at bay, surrounded by a host of Allied hounds. As Germany’s military situation deteriorated, a group … Another big question is whether Montgomery would have pulled it off if Rommel, who was convalescing in Europe on October 23, had been in charge, rather than his deputy, General Stumme. Erwin Rommel - Erwin Rommel - Normandy and conspiracy: In 1944 Rommel was entrusted with the defense of France’s Channel coast against a possible Allied invasion. Rommel was never a good general. By Joseph M. Horodyski. As early as 1950, Bernard Montg… Warning: don't read this book if Monty is your hero! Erwin Rommel. In Patton, Montgomery, Rommel, one of Britain's most accomplished military scholars presents an unprecedented study of the land war in the North African and European theaters, as well as their chief commanders--three men who also happened to be the most compelling dramatis personae of World War II.. Trouble with fuel supplies delayed Rommel’s next advance until the 31 st of August. On one hand, he fought for Nazi Germany and conquered all of North Africa and lead the invasion of France. Leaving aside the reality that Montgomery was not always quite the brave gallant hero the british crown historians and media make out. Rommel, the master of the impromptu battle, … T.L. ‘ His father, also named Erwin, was a schoolmaster and the son of a schoolmaster. Erwin Rommel. I think you have to put Guderian above Rommel in terms of influence and impact on the German army. Defeated by General Bernard Montgomery's Desert Rats at the battle of El Alamein, Rommel nevertheless claimed that his battles against the British were chivalrous affairs and … This speech marked one of the turning points of the war. He left Africa in mid 1943 on a pretext of ill health and just over a year later he was dead at the hands of the Führer for his part in Hitler’s failed bomb assassinations. The second World War is not their first war. Field Marshall Erwin Rommel’s Defense of Normandy During World War II. ... Bernard Montgomery. They trudged to the top and descended, and honour … Erwin Rommel was a German Field Marshal during that same era. Seen as one of the most able commanders of the enemy forces during WWII, he was greatly known as the Desert Fox. Montgomery and Rommel were great adversaries in the WWII front lines; their sons, on the other hand,... A kind of apathy took hold of us as we issued orders for all existing positions to be held on instructions from the highest authority.” Montgomery was now piling on … Updated February 03, 2020. Hitler ordered the Afrika Korps to fight to the last but Rommel refused to carry out this order. Oct 29, 2018. This speech marked one of the turning points of the war. https://www.thoughtco.com/field-marshal-bernard-montgomery-2360162 Monty had two big successes: he took over a disheartened British Eighth army in North Africa, binged them up—one of Montgomery's favorite terms—and gave the Allies their first major victories over the Nazis at El Alamein, defeating Field Marshal Irwin Rommel. #1. The British thwarted the attack and Monty's 8th Army then gained the initiative, and did not let up! Their only child, Manfred, died in 2013. Many in the Allied command considered Montgomery to be arrogant and self-infatuated, while he viewed himself as the world's greatest military mind. Rommel was not getting any supplies thru and what men he had were alot of Italians who did not want to fight. Popularly known as The Desert Fox, Erwin Rommel is seen as the driving force that led the Afrika Korps in pursuit of the Eight Armyin the battle of El Alamein. Erwin Rommel was a great tactician, arguably the best one during the World War II. He believed Montgomery would have withdrawn. Rommel lacked much in terms of strategy. Although I'm not sure I would say that Patton was over promoted. The World War II phase of the career of controversial American general George S. Patton. G erman Field Marshal Erwin Rommel developed a reputation as one of Germany's most popular and heroic soldiers of World War II. Bernard Montgomery born November 17, 1887. Glyn Harper's title might oversell El Alamein's significance, but he's put his usual attention to detail into his analysis. What did you love best about Patton, Montgomery, Rommel? First was to get Churchill off his back with regard to an early advance and the other was to de-mythologise Rommel … The smart and lazy ones I make my commanders. 3 – Rommel was an effective teacher as well as a military leader. Bernard Montgomery was one of the British top Generals during WWII — commander of the Eight Army known as the Desert Rats. However, his defeat against the allied forces in El Alamein was a defining moment in his commandership. Rommel was respected and feared in the same time, and his enemies gave him the nickname “Desert Fox” for his intelligence, wittiness, innovative strategy and military genius. Herr Professor Rommel was much respected in Heidenheim. Montgomery’s Battle of el-Alamein and Rommel’s retreat, 1942–43. Hitler, yemach shmo, did not give importance to the campaign in Northern Africa, so he did not give Rommel the proper supplies. Rommel's plan was to have German infantrymen and tanks confront the Allies on the beaches and kick them back into the sea, to prevent the landing troops from … I believe that the Rommel vs Montgomery question should be answered this way: Montgomery understood the value of planning and logistics. Not to say he was a bad general - Rommel is overrated and Montgomery underrated - but I think given Rommel's lack of supplies, the first phase of El Alamein requiring all out commitment on the German's part isn't quite as much to Montgomery's credit as you do. was quite happy to dominate Europe and to leave the control of Africa to the British and French. The Independent. Montgomery emphatically did not copy Auchinlek's battle plan. they learned their leadership in the trenches or wherever of World War one. Also, his sarcasm is very humorous at times. Gertrude, Rommel’s illegitimate daughter, passed away in 2000. Early authors such as Desmond Young and Basil Liddell Hart mention "the Rommel legend" in their respective books. Of your other leaders that you'll be exploring over the coming nights is that this is the war we associate with them. More or less, yeah I agree. His competence was in knowing that Rommel was way out of his league and being very cautious. Montgomery and Rommel were great adversaries in the WWII front lines; their sons, on the other hand, David Bernard Montgomery and Manfred Rommel had developed a strong bond — a friendship that transcended even one of the world’s biggest wars. “One of my father’s sadnesses was that he never met Rommel. Rommel was not a Nazi. He famously lacked diplomacy and tact when dealing with others. Erwin Rommel was the German field marshal who led the German and Italian forces in North Africa during the Second World War. Rommel was stunned by the reply and later wrote, “For the first time in the African campaign I did not know what to do. Rommel ran out of supplies. Blood, Sweat, Brain. Rommel was never a good general. Erwin Rommel. Sweat saves blood, blood saves lives, but brains saves both. I think Rommel was a much better battlefield general then Monty. If I were Montgomery, we wouldn’t still be here,” Field Marshal Erwin Rommel said as the Afrika Korps continued pressing against El Alamein in the late summer of 1942. He believed Montgomery would have withdrawn. Rommel was not given to retreats, yet he had little confidence of defeating the Eighth Army. The master of the war of movement then developed an unusual inventiveness in the erection of coastal defense works. The Second Battle of El Alamein was fought from October 23, 1942 to November 5, 1942 during World War II (1939-1945) and was the turning point of the campaign in the Western Desert. But adaptation to unplanned events and circumstances is not a weakness, but a strength, to an operational commander. Rommel lacked much in terms of strategy. Rommel, sick at heart and now seriously ill after two years of constant … As Rommel did with inferior numbers in North Africa. On October 14, 1944, German Gen. Erwin Rommel, nicknamed “the Desert Fox,” is given the option of facing a public trial for treason, as a co-conspirator in the Berlichtingen, while I think Rommel, manstein and Guderian are obsiously generals of greatness, they did lose to Zhukov and Monty. But I think that Montgomery has an undeserved bad … Rommel knew that a major attack was inevitable, and did his best to prepare for it.
Adrian And Emma-jean Music Hallelujah, 480th Not A Fighter Squadron, Walmart Deodorant Secret, Sar Bronze Good Citizenship Medal, Overweight Corridor Long Beach Warehouse, Water Festival Beaufort, Sc 2021,